SEARCH
You are in browse mode. You must login to use MEMORY

   Log in to start


From course:

EU Recht (Week 1)

» Start this Course
(Practice similar questions for free)
Question:

Define the no-horizontal-direct-effect rule (Marshall) in regards to Dori.

Author: Bas Dubbelman



Answer:

The definition: 1. Textual argument - Directives are binding for all of the MS (has to be adressed) 2. Estoppel argument - The direct effect for directives exists to prevent a MS from taking advantage of its own failure to comply with EU law 3. Systematic argument - If horizontal direct effect was given to directives, the distinction between directives and regulations would disappear 4. Legal certainty - Since directives were not published, they must not impose obligations on those to whom they are not addressed


0 / 5  (0 ratings)

1 answer(s) in total